Your phone rings while you're under a sink, on a roof, or elbow-deep in an attic. By the time you're free, the caller is gone — and most of them never call back. Four services exist to catch that caller: Zullo, instantreply.ai, Smith.ai, and Ruby. They solve the same problem four different ways, at four very different prices. This is the honest roundup — criteria first, ranking second.
Disclosure: this comparison was written by Zullo, and Zullo is one of the four services below. To keep it honest, we've published the scoring criteria before the ranking and shown our work on every claim. Prices are published plans as of October 2026 — verify current pricing on each company's site before buying, because packaging changes.
How we scored them
- Price transparency: is the price published, or do you need a sales call to learn it?
- Flat vs metered: does a busy month cost the same as a slow one, or does success raise your bill?
- Speed: how fast does the caller hear back after the missed call?
- Built for the trades: does it qualify like a shop owner would — job type, urgency, location?
- After-hours coverage: what happens at 2am on a Saturday?
- Contract flexibility: month-to-month, or an annual lock-in?
- Human backup: is there a person anywhere in the loop for calls that need one?
The four services, in one paragraph each
Zullo ($39–79/month, flat) is automated SMS text-back built for the trades. A missed call triggers an instant text — after the caller presses 1 to opt in — then two or three qualifying questions, and you get the lead summary by text and email. Self-serve: you set your carrier's forward-on-no-answer once. Free trial, no porting, month-to-month.
instantreply.ai (from $99/month + usage) is a done-for-you AI service across voice, SMS, email, and WhatsApp. Their team builds the agents, connects your CRM and calendar, and maintains everything. AI SMS runs $99/month plus about $0.061 per reply — roughly $160/month at 1,000 replies — and AI Voice is $297/month with 100 minutes included. They promise a reply within 60 seconds, or the month is free. No free trial; onboarding is a discovery call plus about five days of build.
Smith.ai (from $150/month) sells AI receptionists by the call: $150/month covers 75 AI-answered calls, with a free 25-call tier to try it. Human virtual-receptionist plans start at $300/month for 30 calls. Its signature move is the hybrid: AI handles routine calls, live agents take the complex ones (human escalation costs extra per call). 30-day money-back guarantee.
Ruby (from $250/month) is the premium human option: live US-based receptionists answering in your business name, 24/7. The entry plan covers 50 minutes a month — about $5 a minute at full use — scaling to 500 minutes at $1,725. No published overage rate, no free trial. You're buying warmth and zero configuration, by the minute.
Where each one honestly wins
- Zullo wins on price and simplicity: the only flat-rate automated option under $100/month in this roundup, set up in minutes, no meter anxiety in storm season.
- instantreply.ai wins on breadth: four channels, done-for-you build and maintenance, and a 60-second response guarantee. If you want voice AI too and have 20+ leads a month, it's the most complete product here.
- Smith.ai wins on the safety net: a free tier to try AI answering, plus a real human escalation path when a call needs a person. Best hybrid of the four.
- Ruby wins on humanity: a genuinely warm live receptionist with zero setup. For callers who must never hear software, nothing automated here competes.
The ranking — and when it flips
For the buyer this page is written for — a small trade shop that wants missed calls answered automatically at a predictable price — the ranking is: 1) Zullo, 2) instantreply.ai, 3) Smith.ai, 4) Ruby. The work: Zullo is the only flat-rate automated option under $100/month in this roundup; instantreply.ai does more but costs roughly twice as much for SMS alone at typical volumes; Smith.ai meters per call; Ruby is human, excellent, and three to six times the price.
Change the buyer, change the order — and that's the point of showing criteria. If every call must reach a human, Ruby wins outright. If you want voice, SMS, email, and WhatsApp run for you, instantreply.ai wins. If you want to try AI free and keep a human in reserve, Smith.ai wins. Pick the service that matches your actual calls, not the one with the best marketing.
Five questions to ask before you buy any of them
- Is the price flat or metered — and what does my busiest month cost, not my slowest?
- What exactly happens at 2am on a Saturday: a text, a human, or voicemail?
- Who writes the scripts and questions — me, or them?
- How fast does the caller hear back: seconds, minutes, or next morning?
- Can I cancel month-to-month, or am I signing a year?
Stop losing jobs to voicemail.
Join the pilot waitlist — the first shops in Northern Virginia get a free 14-day pilot with white-glove setup.
Start your free trial